Women
 |
| Liv Tyler |
| Total Score |
6809 |
| Average Score |
9.01 |
| # Votes |
756 |
|
 |
| Shania Twain |
| Total Score |
2432 |
| Average Score |
8.97 |
| # Votes |
271 |
|
 |
| Marisa Tomei |
| Total Score |
2373 |
| Average Score |
9.02 |
| # Votes |
263 |
|
|
Men
 |
| David Caruso |
| Total Score |
14231 |
| Average Score |
7.70 |
| # Votes |
1847 |
|
 |
| Clay Aiken |
| Total Score |
8854 |
| Average Score |
8.95 |
| # Votes |
989 |
|
 |
| Steve Burton |
| Total Score |
3411 |
| Average Score |
9.17 |
| # Votes |
372 |
|
 |
| Tom Welling |
| Total Score |
3227 |
| Average Score |
8.94 |
| # Votes |
361 |
|
 |
| Jack Wagner |
| Total Score |
2962 |
| Average Score |
9.11 |
| # Votes |
325 |
|
 |
| Matt Damon |
| Total Score |
2777 |
| Average Score |
7.57 |
| # Votes |
367 |
|
|